Watch the video at the end of this article.
Introduction
Oklahoma country music superstar Toby Keith died last night after a three-year battle with stomach cancer. In the wake of his passing, tributes poured in for the 62-year-old hitmaker whose booming voice, patriotic anthems, and barroom bravado shaped the sound of American country for more than three decades. But alongside the celebrations of his life came renewed attention to the part of Keith that never softened even in his final years—the sharp opinions, the long-simmering rivalries, and the artists he never quite forgave.
Keith, famous for his platinum records and his unapologetic persona, was never one to hold his tongue. Behind the scenes, away from the spotlight, he spoke with a candidness that could cut deep, and shortly before his death, he openly named six fellow musicians he had little love for. Some were rivals, others were simply artists he didn’t respect. What he left behind was not a list of petty grudges, but a revealing window into the fiercely principled man behind the music.
1. Natalie Maines: The Feud That Defined an Era
Perhaps no rivalry in early-2000s country music was as explosive as the one between Toby Keith and Natalie Maines of the Dixie Chicks. Their clash unfolded in the tense aftermath of 9/11, a period when American patriotism surged and emotions ran hot. Keith—whose father had died in a car accident months before the attacks—channeled his grief and anger into Courtesy of the Red, White, and Blue (The Angry American), a song that became a rallying cry for some and a flashpoint for others.
Maines was among the critics. In 2002, she publicly condemned the song as offensive and overly aggressive, arguing it reinforced negative stereotypes about country music. Keith fired back, dismissing her critique and mocking her inability to write her own material. The feud quickly spilled from interviews onto the stage: Keith famously displayed a doctored image of Maines alongside Saddam Hussein during his concerts—a jab he later admitted went too far.
The rift intensified in 2003 after Maines told a London audience she was ashamed President George W. Bush was from Texas, igniting a nationwide backlash against her band. By the time the two artists faced off at the ACM Awards that year, the feud had become symbolic—two competing visions of patriotism, pride, and artistic expression.
Yet by August 2003, Keith began to rethink the bitterness. A friend’s personal tragedy prompted him to reflect on the pettiness of the conflict. He later admitted he felt embarrassed by how extreme things had become, saying: “I’m not that mean.” Though the peace was never public, the flame eventually cooled.
2. Kris Kristofferson: Rumors, Rage, and a Backstage Standoff
One of the most persistent legends surrounding Toby Keith is a supposed backstage blowup with Kris Kristofferson at Willie Nelson’s 70th birthday concert in 2003. Actor Ethan Hawke described the scene in a 2009 Rolling Stone article as a tense, politically charged confrontation: Keith allegedly warned Kristofferson to avoid “lefty s***,” and the veteran songwriter fired back, challenging Keith’s patriotism and military bravado.
Keith denied the story outright, calling it “a fictitious lying thing.” Kristofferson initially dismissed it too—though in later interviews he admitted he couldn’t remember whether it happened. Whether true or not, the tale took on a life of its own, reinforcing the mythic image of two towering figures—one a decorated veteran, one a fiery showman—colliding in a moment of cultural and political friction.
3. Taylor Swift: Admiration, Irony, and an Unspoken Rift
When old footage resurfaced of a 15-year-old Taylor Swift expressing awe toward Toby Keith, it reignited a forgotten chapter of country music history. Keith was a co-founder of Big Machine Records, the label that launched Swift’s career. Though he left the company just months after her signing, he retained a stake—and likely profited from her meteoric rise.
Swift once described the “electric power” of being in the same room as Keith. But the admiration didn’t last forever—at least not publicly. Their political worlds diverged sharply. Keith’s post-9/11 anthems were embraced by conservatives, while Swift became one of the most influential liberal voices in modern pop culture.
When Big Machine was later sold to Scooter Braun—giving him control of Swift’s early masters—the rupture between Swift and her former label became one of the decade’s biggest music industry battles. Ironically, the ordeal traced back to the label Keith helped build.
Swift did not publicly comment on Keith’s death in 2024. But the video of her teenage self praising him remains a poignant reminder of their intertwined beginnings—even as their paths diverged dramatically.
4. Donald Trump: Patriotism Without Allegiance
Toby Keith’s political identity was complicated. Though frequently embraced as a MAGA icon—thanks in part to his performance at Donald Trump’s 2017 inauguration—Keith resisted labels. His ties to Trump were born less of loyalty and more of duty. When asked why he performed at the inauguration, he replied simply: “When the president asks and you’re able to go, you go.”
He was a registered Democrat until 2008, then became an independent. He voted for presidents from both parties, expressed disillusionment with politics as a whole, and criticized the system as a “dumpster fire.” Even so, Trump awarded him the National Medal of Arts in 2021—a moment that cemented their complicated political association.
A Legacy Larger Than Controversy
Beyond the sparring matches and political soundbites, Keith’s life was defined by music. Born Toby Keith Covel in Clinton, Oklahoma, he rose from working oil fields and playing semi-pro football to becoming one of country music’s most successful artists. His career produced:
-
25+ million albums sold
-
Seven Grammy nominations
-
Fourteen ACM Awards
-
Two Entertainer of the Year wins
-
Five albums topping the Billboard 200
His biggest commercial peak came with Unleashed (2002) and Shock’n Y’all (2003)—records that blended rowdy celebration with raw patriotism. Songs like Beer for My Horses, I Love This Bar, and American Soldier revealed a man who straddled bravado and sentiment with equal conviction.
His induction into the Country Music Hall of Fame—announced just one day after his death—cements his legacy as one of the genre’s defining voices.
The Man Behind the Fights
Toby Keith was larger than life—a storyteller, a provocateur, a patriot, and occasionally a lightning rod. His feuds, his clashes, and his unfiltered honesty were part of that persona. But underneath the bravado was a man of complexity, contradictions, and deeply held convictions.
The six names he carried with him late into life don’t paint a portrait of vindictiveness. They reveal a man who believed in loyalty, who defended what mattered to him, and who—rightly or wrongly—refused to apologize for being himself.
In the end, his story is not only about the battles he fought, but the legacy he left behind—a musical catalogue that shaped a generation, and a life lived boldly, loudly, and without hesitation.